The Short Answer
Knackwurst (often spelled knockwurst in the US) is a short, plump, smoked, fully cooked sausage with a smooth, fine texture and a strong garlic flavor. Its tight casing makes an audible snap when you bite it, which is where the name comes from: knacken means to crack.
Bratwurst is usually a fresh (raw), longer and slimmer sausage seasoned with marjoram, white pepper, nutmeg or mace, and sometimes caraway. It has to be cooked through before eating.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Knackwurst | Bratwurst | |
|---|---|---|
| Typical shape | Short and thick, often about 4 in long | Longer and slimmer; size varies a lot by region |
| Texture | Fine, smooth, emulsified | Ranges from fine (Nürnberger) to coarse (Thüringer) |
| Meat | Pork and beef, sometimes veal | Mostly pork; sometimes veal or beef |
| Key flavor | Garlic, smoke, pepper | Marjoram, warm spice, sometimes caraway or lemon |
| Cured with nitrite? | Yes, so it stays pink | Usually not, so it turns gray-white |
| Smoked? | Yes | Usually not |
| Sold as | Fully cooked | Mostly raw; some pre-cooked versions |
| Associated region | Northern Germany | Franconia, Thuringia and many others |
| Classic serving | With sauerkraut, potatoes and mustard | Grilled in a roll with mustard; with kraut and potato salad |
What Is Knackwurst?
Knackwurst is a Brühwurst, a scalded sausage made from a finely chopped batter of meat, fat and ice. It is stuffed into casings, dried, smoked and cooked. It is usually associated with northern Germany, especially Holstein and the Hamburg area, and German immigrants made it a deli-counter standard in American cities. You will also find regional relatives, such as Berlin’s Knacker, that share the snap but differ in grind and seasoning.
Because it is cured and fully cooked, knackwurst only needs reheating. Its garlic and smoke make it bolder than most German sausages, though it is not hot.
What Is Bratwurst?
Bratwurst is a whole family of German sausages rather than a single recipe. Some sources count dozens of regional styles. Most are fresh pork sausages, sometimes with veal, seasoned with marjoram and warm spices and meant to be grilled or pan-fried. The two best-known German styles are compared in Nürnberger vs. Thüringer bratwurst. In the US, bratwurst is closely tied to Wisconsin and to Oktoberfest; try our Oktoberfest sausage recipe to make your own.
How They’re Made (and Why It Matters)
- Bratwurst is ground (not emulsified, in most styles), mixed with salt, spices and a little cold water until sticky, stuffed and sold raw. With no cure and no smoke, it has a clean, fresh pork flavor and a pale color once cooked.
- Knackwurst is made with nitrite curing salt, chopped to a fine emulsion with ice (much like a frankfurter), stuffed, dried, smoked and cooked. The cure gives it the pink interior and cured “hot dog-like” flavor. The emulsion gives the smooth bite. The smoke and the drying tighten the casing for the snap.
For more on how ingredients like ice, fat and curing salt shape a sausage, see what’s in a German sausage.
How to Cook Each
Knackwurst (pre-cooked):
- Heat in hot water that is not boiling for 8–12 minutes, or
- Grill or pan-brown over medium heat for 6–10 minutes, turning often, until hot through. Some cooks split it lengthwise first.
Bratwurst (raw):
- Simmer gently in beer or water for 10–15 minutes, then sear, or
- Pan-fry or grill over moderate heat for 15–20 minutes, until the center reaches 160°F (71°C).
Don’t boil either one hard, or the casings will split. Our guide to the best way to cook German sausage goes into detail.
Which Should You Choose?
- Pick knackwurst for a quick, robust plate with sauerkraut and potatoes, for a hearty sandwich on rye, or whenever you want garlic and smoke. Because it is pre-cooked, it is also a fast weeknight option.
- Pick bratwurst for cookouts, beer brats, buns with mustard and kraut, or when you want a juicier, milder sausage.
Both suit sauerkraut, mustard and potato salad, so serving a few of each at a German-themed dinner works well. For the wider German lineup, see our guide to popular German sausages.
Making Knackwurst at Home
Knackwurst is an intermediate project. It combines the emulsion technique used for weisswurst with curing and smoking:
- Cure and chop. Pork and beef (about 2:1) plus pork fat, with salt and Cure #1 at 2.5 g per kg of meat, processed with ice into a smooth batter. Keep it at or below about 54°F (12°C). Add plenty of fresh garlic, plus white pepper, a little coriander and mace.
- Stuff. Use 32–38 mm hog casings and twist into short, plump links.
- Dry and smoke. Dry the surface, then smoke at low temperatures (roughly 130–150°F / 54–66°C) until the links are reddish-brown.
- Cook. Finish by poaching in water at about 165–175°F (74–79°C), or by raising the smoker temperature, until the center reaches 155–160°F (68–71°C).
- Chill. Cool quickly in ice water, then refrigerate.
Cure #1 is necessary here because the sausage spends time at smoking temperatures where harmful bacteria could otherwise grow. Measure it precisely with a scale accurate to 0.1 g.