Hot Dog, Frankfurter, Wiener, Frank: What’s the Difference?
All of these are sausages, but not all sausages are hot dogs. “Sausage” is the broad category. A hot dog is one specific type: finely ground meat whipped into a smooth paste (an emulsion), cured, usually smoked, and fully cooked before it’s sold.
- Frankfurter. Named after Frankfurt, Germany. Traditionally pork in a thin sheep casing, smoked and then simmered.
- Wiener. Named after Vienna (Wien), and closely related. Wiener Würstchen often contain a mix of pork and beef. Confusingly, Austrians often call them “Frankfurter”, while Germans call them “Wiener”.
- Frank. An American shortening of frankfurter.
- Hot dog. The American name for the same style of sausage, and also for the sausage served in a bun.
In everyday North American usage, hot dog, frank, frankfurter and wiener are essentially interchangeable. Differences in meat (all-beef vs pork-and-beef), size and casing are about brand and style, not about the name. A “sausage” in the US, by contrast, usually means a coarser, often raw sausage such as Italian, bratwurst or breakfast sausage, which needs full cooking.
As for which sausage is good for hot dogs: if you mean a sausage in a bun, almost any grilled sausage works. But for the classic smooth texture and snap, you need an emulsified frankfurter-style sausage like the one below.
What Hot Dogs Are Made Of
Commercial hot dogs are made from beef, pork, chicken or turkey trimmings, chopped with ice, salt, spices and a nitrite cure into a smooth batter. They’re stuffed, cooked and often smoked. Our separate explainer on what hot dogs are actually made of goes through the labels, mechanically separated meat and the “skinless” peeling process. If you’re wondering about a specific chain, we also answer whether 7-Eleven hot dogs are beef or pork.
Making your own means you choose the cuts, the salt level and the casing.
Equipment
- A meat grinder with a fine plate (3–4.5 mm)
- A food processor with at least a 7-cup (1.6-litre) bowl. This is what makes the emulsion.
- A sausage stuffer. A piston stuffer is far easier than a grinder attachment.
- Sheep casings (20–24 mm) for a snappy natural-casing dog, or small-diameter collagen casings
- An accurate digital scale that reads to 0.1 g for the curing salt
- An instant-read thermometer, plus a smoker or a large pot for poaching
Homemade Hot Dog Recipe
This makes about 1.2 kg (2.6 lb), or roughly 16–20 hot dogs depending on casing size.
| Ingredient | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Beef chuck, cubed | 500 g (1.1 lb) | |
| Pork shoulder, cubed | 300 g (10½ oz) | |
| Pork back fat, cubed | 200 g (7 oz) | |
| Crushed ice or ice water | 150 g (5 oz) | Keeps the emulsion cold |
| Salt | 18 g | About 1.8% of the meat weight |
| Cure #1 (Prague Powder #1) | 2.5 g | 0.25% of meat weight. Weigh it, don’t guess. |
| Non-fat dry milk powder | 25 g | Optional binder, helps hold fat and water |
| Sugar or corn syrup | 5 g | |
| Sweet paprika | 2 tsp | |
| Ground coriander | 1 tsp | |
| Ground white pepper | 1 tsp | |
| Garlic powder | ¾ tsp | |
| Mustard powder | ½ tsp | |
| Ground mace or nutmeg | ¼ tsp |
All-beef version. Use 800 g beef chuck and 200 g beef fat trimmings, or a well-marbled brisket point. It’s the classic deli and kosher-style choice, and it’s the base for a halal hot dog if you use halal-certified beef with sheep, collagen or cellulose casings.
Chicken version. Use 900 g boneless chicken thigh with some skin left on and 100 g chicken skin or fat. Cook to 74°C (165°F). Our pork vs. chicken sausage guide has more on working with poultry.
Cure #1 is a mix of salt and sodium nitrite (about 6.25%). It gives hot dogs their pink colour and cured flavour, and it guards against botulism during slow, low-temperature smoking. Use only the amount the manufacturer specifies. The 0.25%-of-meat-weight rate above is the standard dose for Cure #1. Keep it labelled and away from regular salt.
Step by Step
- Cure and chill the meat. Toss the cubed beef, pork and fat with the salt and Cure #1. Spread it on a tray and freeze for 30–45 minutes until it’s firm at the edges but not frozen solid. Chill the grinder parts and the food processor bowl too.
- Grind twice. Grind through a medium plate, chill again, then grind through the fine plate.
- Emulsify. Working in batches if needed, put the ground meat, ice, milk powder, sugar and spices in the food processor. Process until the mix becomes a smooth, pale, sticky paste, usually 2–4 minutes. Check the temperature often. Keep the paste below about 10°C (50°F), and colder is better. If it climbs, stop and chill the bowl and paste in the freezer for 15 minutes before you carry on. Heat is what breaks an emulsion.
- Test. Poach a spoonful of paste in simmering water. It should be springy and juicy, not crumbly or greasy. Adjust the seasoning if needed.
- Stuff. Load the stuffer, packing the paste down to get rid of air pockets. Fill the casings firmly, then twist or tie them into 13–15 cm (5–6 in) links.
- Rest overnight. Hang the links or lay them on a rack in the fridge, uncovered, overnight. This lets the cure develop and the casings dry slightly so they take smoke well.
- Smoke or poach.
- Smoker: Start at about 55–60°C (130–140°F) with no smoke for 30–60 minutes to dry the surface. Then apply light smoke at about 70–80°C (160–180°F) until the internal temperature reaches 71°C (160°F).
- No smoker: Poach in water held at 75–80°C (167–176°F). Never let it boil. Poach until the centre reaches 71°C (160°F). Add a pinch of smoked paprika to the recipe if you want a hint of smoke.
- Shock. Plunge the cooked hot dogs into ice water for 10 minutes. This stops the cooking, tightens the casings and keeps them from wrinkling. Pat dry and refrigerate.
Troubleshooting
- Greasy, with fat pooling or leaking out. The emulsion got too warm and broke. Keep everything colder, and work in smaller batches.
- Grainy or crumbly. Too little salt, not enough processing, or the paste was overheated. Salt is what extracts the binding proteins, so don’t cut it drastically.
- No snap. Collagen casings give a gentler bite than sheep casings. Smoking at too high a temperature can also toughen or split casings.
- Grey instead of pink. The cure was missed or under-measured. Weigh it on an accurate scale.
- Split casings. Overstuffed, or cooked too hot. Hold the smoker and water temperatures steady.
Cooking and Serving Homemade Hot Dogs
Your hot dogs are already fully cooked, so serving them is just reheating:
- Grill. Use medium heat and turn until blistered and heated through.
- Pan. Sear in a little butter over medium-low heat, rolling them often.
- Simmered. Heat gently in water just below a simmer. For beer-braised dogs, simmer them in lager with sliced onions for about 10 minutes, then sear briefly.
- Steamed. The street-cart classic, which keeps them plump.
Storage
Cooked, chilled hot dogs keep for about a week in the fridge in a sealed container. Vacuum-sealed, they freeze well for two to three months. Thaw them in the fridge. Homemade hot dogs are just one branch of a big family. Our guide to sausage types from around the world covers the rest.