The Short Answer
Nürnberger Rostbratwurst is a small, thin, finely ground pork sausage, about the size of a finger. It is dominated by marjoram and grilled over beechwood, and it is served several at a time. Thüringer Rostbratwurst is a long, fairly slim, medium-coarse sausage seasoned with marjoram, caraway and garlic. It is grilled over charcoal and served singly in a roll that is too short for it.
Both are from neighboring regions of central Germany (Franconia in northern Bavaria, and Thuringia), and both have EU Protected Geographical Indication (PGI) status. That means only sausages made in those regions to the registered specification can carry the names.
Side-by-Side Comparison
| Nürnberger Rostbratwurst | Thüringer Rostbratwurst | |
|---|---|---|
| Region | City of Nuremberg (Franconia, Bavaria) | State of Thuringia |
| Size | Small: roughly 7–9 cm long, about 20–25 g each | Long: generally at least 15 cm, often closer to 20 cm |
| Casing | Thin sheep casing | Natural hog (or sheep) casing |
| Grind | Fine | Medium to coarse |
| Meat | Pork | Pork, sometimes with small amounts of veal or beef |
| Key seasonings | Marjoram (prominent), pepper, mace, sometimes lemon, ginger or cardamom | Marjoram, caraway, garlic, pepper, nutmeg |
| Traditional cooking | Grilled over a beechwood fire | Grilled over charcoal |
| Traditional serving | Six to twelve on a plate with sauerkraut or potato salad, or three in a roll (Drei im Weggla) | One in a crusty roll with mustard, ends sticking out |
| Protected status | PGI | PGI |
Nürnberger Rostbratwurst
Nuremberg’s little bratwurst is one of Germany’s best-known regional foods. Records of bratwurst-making in the city are commonly said to date back to the early 1300s, though, as with many old food histories, exact dates are hard to verify.
Under its protected status, a “Nürnberger Rostbratwurst” must be made in the city of Nuremberg. It is a pork sausage with a fine texture, stuffed into narrow sheep casings and seasoned heavily with marjoram. That gives it a fragrant, herbal flavor that is distinctly different from other brats.
How it is served:
- On a plate: In Nuremberg’s taverns, the sausages are grilled over a beechwood fire and served in groups (six, eight, ten or twelve), traditionally on a pewter plate, with sauerkraut or potato salad and horseradish or mustard.
- In a roll: At snack stands, three sausages go into a bread roll, a serving locally called Drei im Weggla.
- Sour: Saure Zipfel (“sour tips”) are Franconian bratwursts gently simmered in a vinegar, onion and spice broth instead of grilled.
Thüringer Rostbratwurst
The Thuringian bratwurst is Germany’s classic grill sausage. A 1404 document from the town of Arnstadt is often cited as the earliest written mention of a bratwurst in Thuringia.
It is longer and coarser than the Nürnberger, and its seasoning is bolder. Caraway and garlic join the marjoram, which gives it a more robust, savory flavor. The protected specification requires it to be made in Thuringia.
How it is served: Grilled over charcoal, often brushed or basted while it cooks, then tucked into a crusty roll (Brötchen) that is deliberately shorter than the sausage. Mustard is the standard condiment, and Thuringian mustard is the local choice. Many traditionalists frown on ketchup.
Why Two Neighboring Regions Ended Up So Different
Regional sausage styles in Germany developed through local butcher guilds, local spice trade, and city rules about sausage size and content. Nuremberg was a major trading city, and its finely seasoned small sausage became a civic emblem. One popular, unverified story claims the small size made the sausages easy to pass through keyholes after curfew. Thuringia’s sausage developed as a hearty, coarse country sausage built for the open grill. Today both are proudly defended by local producers, and both are protected brands.
For how these fit into the broader bratwurst family, see our guide to popular German sausages.
Making Each Style at Home
Outside their home regions you can’t legally sell sausages under these protected names, but you can make your own “Nürnberger-style” and “Thüringer-style” brats. Both start like our Oktoberfest sausage recipe: chill, grind, mix until sticky, stuff and rest. Both are fresh sausages, with no cure needed.
Nürnberger-Style (per 1 kg)
- 700 g pork shoulder + 300 g pork belly
- 17 g salt
- 2 g ground white pepper
- 3 g dried marjoram (generous, about 1½ Tbsp)
- 0.5 g ground mace
- A pinch each of ground ginger and cardamom
- Zest of ½ lemon (optional)
- 60–80 ml ice water
- Grind: fine (3 mm plate), ideally twice
- Casing: sheep casings about 20–22 mm, twisted into 7–9 cm links
Thüringer-Style (per 1 kg)
- 800 g pork shoulder + 200 g pork belly (or replace 100–150 g with veal)
- 18 g salt
- 2.5 g ground black pepper
- 2 g dried marjoram
- 2 g caraway (whole or lightly crushed)
- 1–2 garlic cloves, finely minced
- A pinch of nutmeg
- 80–100 ml ice water
- Grind: medium-coarse (5–8 mm plate)
- Casing: hog casings around 26–28 mm, linked at about 15–20 cm
Fry a test patty of each before stuffing. The difference in marjoram, caraway and garlic shows up clearly when you taste them side by side.
Cooking and Serving Tips
- Nürnberger: Because they are small, grill or pan-fry them over medium heat for about 8–10 minutes, turning often, until they reach 160°F (71°C). Serve with sauerkraut and horseradish, or three in a roll.
- Thüringer: Grill over medium charcoal heat for about 15–20 minutes, turning regularly, until they reach 160°F. Serve in a crusty roll with mustard.
For more on grilling and pan-frying fresh brats without splitting them, see the best way to cook German sausage. If you’d like a smoked, garlicky alternative, compare knackwurst vs. bratwurst, and if you want more heat, see spicy German sausages.